How The Monkey Landed Here

Founded in 2009, Warren Exchange is located right on Main Street in the smallest town in the smallest state! Warren, RI.  Originally opened as a coin and cash for gold shop, we expanded to buy and sell everything, from one marble up to an entire estate.  We have a steady stream of pickers and antique enthusiasts that visit daily, and our inventory is always changing.

Mataya (Tara) (Proprietor)

That is me!  I have always loved flea markets and buying and selling. So many interesting items have come in and out of this shop, carried by the most fascinating people in the world….if not the UNIVERSE!!! I love this job!

April (curator)

The Master of Disaster, April handles our off site group shop and Antique Mall locations.

We Buy & Sell Everything but the Monkey!

At Warren Exchange, we stay true to the motto “We buy one marble up to an entire estate” No matter what you bring in, we can give you an appraisal and a cash offer to purchase the item.
It could be your Grandfather’s WWII army knife or your great Aunt Ida’s sewing basket….we have bought and sold everything. Having been in the business since 2009, if we can’t figure it out, we have a built network of experts who we can call to help.

Take a look as some of the items we buy:

We Always Pay Cash!
Bring Your Items In For A Free Evaluation, email, or Call To Make An Appointment For A House Call.

Coin Collections & Cash for Gold

Any American* silver coin (Dime, Quarter, and Half Dollar**) before 1964 has a precious metal value, and some have a numismatic value. A Numismatic coin is a coin whose value or price depends more on its date, condition, rarity value, connection to history, aesthetic attraction and mint mark of the coin, than its face value.
Bring in ALL of your coins, we will sort and appraise your collection and make a cash offer.

*Foreign coins can also have a precious metal value. Each country is different. Bring in your foreign coins for an appraisal as well.

**half dollars from 1965-1969 contain 40% silver and also have a precious metal value. We are always buying precious metals.

Cash for Gold & Silver

We have been buying and selling Gold and Silver jewelry in the same brick and mortar location since 2009. Most of our customers are word or mouth, referral, and repeat customers.
Bring in your collection. We will separate and sort your jewelry, test in in front of you, and give you a cash offer.

We buy all jewelry!

Including costume jewelry. Rhode Island was the jewelry making capital of the world, starting in 1890 hitting its peak in 1940s when RI was producing 80% of all costume jewelry nation wide! (My grandparents actually met in the factory line at Coro manufacturing costume jewelry) April’s mother met her Mother In Law picking for Monet.
Bring in your costume jewelry. Although rare, some costume jewelry is worth more than silver or gold.

Reviews From Our Customers

Excellent4.9 Based on 225 reviews from review us onGwynne A.Gwynne A. ★★★★★ Transparent and honest. Clearly explains process of buying and selling. Will return.Richard D.Richard D. ★★★★★ Diane C.Diane C. ★★★★★ Great experience! Tara took the time to sort through all of the jewelry and gave us a price for each type of metal, including 10K, 14K, silver, and more. There was absolutely no pressure to take her offer.If you have a particular piece of jewelry you’d like priced separately, she’s happy to do that before weighing the metals. Very professional, helpful, and transparent. Highly recommend!Response from the ownerDiane, thank you so much for the wonderful review! I really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience. I always want customers to understand exactly what they have and how I arrive at my offer—and, most importantly, to feel comfortable with absolutely no pressure to sell. It was a pleasure helping you, and thank you for recommending Warren Exchange! ❤️ Mariah K.Mariah K. ★★★★★ Tara is the best! She gave such great prices for everything I was looking to sell. I will be back for sure. 😄Response from the ownerMariah, thank you so much! ❤️ I’m so glad you had a great experience and were happy with the prices I offered. I truly appreciate you choosing Warren Exchange, and I’ll be looking forward to seeing you again! 😄 Jordan R.Jordan R. ★★★★★ Amazing customer service!!Response from the ownerThanks Jordan, come back anytime JaniceJanice ★★★★★ Tara is great, very helpful and patient, she went through my costume jewelry and found gold! She is also great with sterling silver and silver plate.Response from the ownerJanice, thank you so much! ❤️ I love going through those costume jewelry boxes—you never know what might be hiding in there! Finding gold mixed in is always a fun surprise. I really appreciate you trusting me with your jewelry, sterling silver, and silver plate. Thank you for choosing Warren Exchange! Deb D.Deb D. ★★★★★ Stopped inside Warren Exchange to get a price on selling some gold. Right away, Tara was very welcoming and friendly. She explained the process of testing the gold and did all the testing right in front of me. I had gone to a jewelry store in the area and prior to Tara’s and was not happy with what they were offered me. It didn’t sound right and after meeting with Tara, my gut was right. It wasn’t near what Tara offered. I left very happy and will be back! Thank you Tara for being fair and honest!Response from the ownerDeb, thank you so much for taking the time to share this! ❤️ Being transparent about the testing process and making sure you understand exactly what you have and what I’m offering is incredibly important to me. I’m so glad you trusted your gut and stopped in for another opinion—and even happier that you left feeling good about your experience! Thank you for trusting Warren Exchange with your gold. I look forward to seeing you again! Kathy LKathy L ★★★★★ My first time to Warren Exchange. We are moving and had some family silver pieces. Tara is pleasant honest and knowledgeable. Good experience overall.Response from the ownerKathy, thank you so much for stopping in and for the kind words! ❤️ I know that family silver pieces can have a lot of history behind them, so I’m glad I could help make the process comfortable and straightforward. Best of luck with your move, and thank you for choosing Warren Exchange! Karen S.Karen S. ★★★★★ Fair and friendlyPaul G.Paul G. ★★★★★ Been dealing with Tara for a few years , honest & fair, very knowledgeable! All& all, terrific to do business with...Response from the ownerPaul, thank you so much! It means a lot to have customers who continue to come back and do business with me year after year. ❤️ I truly appreciate your trust, your kind words, and your continued support of Warren Exchange. Always a pleasure seeing you! MikeMike ★★★★★ Response from the ownerThanks for the review Mike Cheryl Q.Cheryl Q. ★★★★★ Tara is knowledgeable and helps you understand the process of how selling your valuables works. She is fair and I will continue going to her whenever I have items to sell.Response from the ownerThank you so much for the kind review! ❤️ I believe you should always understand what you have, how I evaluate it, and exactly how I arrive at my offer. I really appreciate your trust and especially appreciate that you’ll continue choosing Warren Exchange when you have items to sell. Looking forward to seeing you again! joe M.joe M. ★★★★★ Tara is so nice and friendly, I was extremely happy with my experience at Warren Exchange. I will definitely be going back. Tara is super honest and I felt very comfortable with what she was telling me about the items I brought to her. Thank you very much!!! Highly recommend!Response from the ownerJoe, thank you so much for such a wonderful review! ❤️ Making sure people feel comfortable, get honest information about their items, and never feel pressured is exactly the experience I want at Warren Exchange. I really appreciate your trust and recommendation, and I look forward to seeing you again! David St. A.David St. A. ★★★★★ This place has something for everyone 💯🫶🫶🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 check then out on Whatnot @warrenexchangeMarianMarian ★★★★★ Very helpful, knowledgeable & sincere! Highly recommended?Response from the ownerThank you so much, Marian, We truly appreciate your kind words. It was a pleasure helping you, and we’re grateful for your recommendation. We look forward to seeing you again soon at Warren Exchange! Susan G.Susan G. ★★★★★ I had a great experience at the Warren Exchange! Tara was very personable and professional - a pleasure to work with. I brought in sterling silverware to sell. She explained the process and I felt she was very fair with the pricing. I would definitely recommend her to others!Response from the ownerThank you so much, Susan, for your wonderful review! It was truly a pleasure meeting and working with you. I’m so glad you had a positive experience and that I could make the process of selling your sterling silverware clear and comfortable. We always strive to be fair, transparent, and welcoming. Your recommendation means a great deal to us, and we hope to see you again at Warren Exchange! Mary B.Mary B. ★★★★★ I had a great experience at Warren Exchange with Tara. She examined each item and gave me a good price for my gold jewelry. I would recommend the Warren Exchange as Tara is professional, knowledgeable, and fair.Response from the ownerThank you so much, Mary, for taking the time to leave such a thoughtful review! It was a pleasure meeting you and helping you with your gold jewelry. We believe every item deserves careful evaluation, and we’re glad you felt the pricing was fair. Your kind words about our professionalism and knowledge mean a lot to us. Thank you for your recommendation, and we look forward to welcoming you back to Warren Exchange in the future! Cindy L.Cindy L. ★★★★★ Great experience and service.Tara was knowledgeable and honest. Would definitely recommend Warren Exchange Ltd.Response from the ownerThank you so much, Cindy! We truly appreciate your kind review. It was a pleasure working with you, and we’re so glad you had a great experience. We always strive to provide honest, knowledgeable service and make every customer feel comfortable throughout the process. Your recommendation means the world to us. We look forward to seeing you again at Warren Exchange!…or at a Pink & Green estate sale 😁 Robin O.Robin O. ★★★★★ I found this shop in my local Reporter publication, and decided to try it out. They were available when I needed them, and straightforward as to what they could/would purchase. I traded in some items that I was no longer using, and walked away with cash - what's better than that?Response from the ownerThank you so much, Robin! We’re so glad you found us through the Reporter and decided to stop by. It was a pleasure working with you, and we’re happy we could make the process simple, straightforward, and worthwhile. Turning items you no longer use into cash is exactly what we’re here for! We truly appreciate your support and hope to see you again at Warren Exchange. Josh S.Josh S. ★★★★★ This place is great! The owner is such a great lady who is fair and treats her customers well! Highly recommendedResponse from the ownerThank you so much, Josh! Your kind words truly mean a lot. We work hard to treat every customer with honesty, fairness, and respect, so it’s wonderful to hear that reflected in your experience. We sincerely appreciate your recommendation and look forward to seeing you again at Warren Exchange! Matthew M.Matthew M. ★★★★★ Response from the ownerThanks for the review 😁 Pamela B.Pamela B. ★★★★★ I was very pleased with my visit today. Everyone was very friendly and helpful. I think the price I received was more than fair and I would absolutely go back again!Response from the ownerThank you so much, Pamela! We’re thrilled to hear you had such a positive experience. Our goal is to make every visit friendly, helpful, and transparent, and we’re so glad you felt you received a fair price. Your kind words and support mean a lot to us. We look forward to welcoming you back to Warren Exchange anytime! Carol E.Carol E. ★★★★★ I found the proprietor to be honest,frank and refreshingly straightforward. Helpful in my decision making by providing straightforward complete answers as to current market conditions for different niches. Definitely a positive experience.Response from the ownerThank you so much, Carol, for your wonderful review! We truly appreciate your kind words. We believe that honesty, transparency, and taking the time to explain current market conditions are essential to helping our customers make informed decisions. We’re so glad you had a positive experience, and we look forward to the opportunity to help you again in the future. Thank you for choosing Warren Exchange! DorothyDorothy ★★★★★ Avram G.Avram G. ★★★★★ Tara was an absolute pleasure to do business with. As personable as she was professional. Highly recommend!Response from the ownerThank you so much for the wonderful review! It was a pleasure meeting you and Im sure this isn't the first time you had to admit... your wife was right! 😊 It was great getting the chance to work with you. I truly appreciate your kind words and your recommendation. My goal is to make every customer feel comfortable while providing an honest and professional experience. Thank you for choosing Warren Exchange! js_loader

In The News

Contact Us